Key findings
- Almost everyone is on the apps: 95% of surveyed operators used at least one online ordering platform, three on average (2023). 75% of independent operators offered marketplace ordering (2022). National benchmark
- Few run their own: only 36% reported direct ordering through their website. National benchmark
- The cost is real: operators paid an average 15% commission per online order; nearly a quarter paid more than 20%. National benchmark
- Guests are open to ordering direct: 72% of quick-service guests say they prefer ordering directly from the restaurant (2025). National benchmark
- Data follows the channel: on a marketplace order, the platform controls the customer data. Only a direct channel with consent lets you build your own guest list.
All figures are national benchmarks from different surveys and years; none is a Florida measurement, and they should not be added together.
How do operators take online orders today?
Most restaurants run several ordering channels at once, and marketplaces lead.
| Indicator | Result | Scope and limits |
|---|---|---|
| Use at least one online ordering solution | 95% | National TouchBistro operator survey, 2023 |
| Average number of ordering solutions | 3 | National Same survey; channels overlap |
| Independents offering marketplace ordering | 75% | National Technomic/Grubhub survey, 2022; the sponsor has a commercial interest |
| Use Uber Eats | 68% | National TouchBistro 2023; multiple answers allowed, so not a share of order volume |
| Offer direct website ordering | 36% | National TouchBistro 2023; often alongside marketplaces |
| Online orders as a share of business | 23% avg. | National TouchBistro 2023; all platforms combined |
Third-party and direct ordering are not an either/or choice. Many restaurants use marketplaces to be discovered and a branded website, app, phone line or POS-linked ordering flow for regulars.
The margin gap
Illustration At an average 15% commission, a restaurant doing $100,000 a month in marketplace sales pays about $15,000 a month in commissions, before any other fees. That is an illustration from a national benchmark, not a Florida fee quote; your contracts, delivery costs and ad spend set your real number.
Work out your own gap with four numbers from your last 90 days:
- Monthly sales through each marketplace.
- Your effective commission rate per platform, including marketing and service fees.
- Average order value and repeat rate by channel.
- The monthly cost of running a direct ordering system.
Every repeat order that moves from a marketplace to your own channel can keep much of that commission in your business, net of your direct-ordering costs. Moving every order isn't realistic: some guests will always choose the app for convenience.
Who owns the customer?
When a guest orders through a marketplace, the platform controls the relationship and most of the data; what you can see depends on its terms and integrations. A direct order lets you build your own guest list, but only if you ask for consent and have a system to store and use it.
One common trap: an "Order Online" button on your website that opens an embedded marketplace checkout. It looks direct, but it may not give you the same data ownership as a true direct transaction. Check where your checkout really runs.
What do guests prefer?
Guests are more willing to order direct than many operators assume.
- In a 2025 guest engagement study, 72% of quick-service guests said they prefer ordering directly from the restaurant over a third party. National
- In a Deloitte consumer survey, 40% of off-premises diners preferred a restaurant-branded website or app, versus 11% for third-party tools. National
These are different surveys with different questions and audiences, and preference is not the same as behavior. Still, they suggest a fast, simple direct option is worth offering and promoting.
A balanced channel playbook
Keep the marketplaces that bring you new guests, and make your own channel the easy choice for everyone who comes back.
- Audit your channels: listing accuracy, menus, ordering friction, how dependent you are on each platform, and whether you collect consent-based guest data.
- Build a fast direct path: direct ordering tied to your POS, quick on a phone, with clear pickup and delivery options and transparent pricing.
- Invite guests to come direct: use direct links, packaging inserts and post-purchase prompts where platform rules allow.
- Measure what matters: direct-order share, contribution margin by channel, repeat-customer rate, average check, cost to acquire a guest, opt-in rate and visit lift.
Delivery logistics, marketplace visibility and neighborhood demand differ for every operator, so set targets from your own numbers, not an industry average.
Sources and methodology
Sources were checked November 19, 2026. Technomic/Grubhub and TouchBistro are national operator studies with different years and samples. Operator adoption, order volume, guest preference and data ownership are separate measures and should not be combined.
Sources
- TouchBistro 2024 State of Restaurants: Platform use, direct ordering, online share and commissions (2023 survey)
- Technomic/Grubhub 2022 online ordering report: Marketplace adoption among independents
- Hospitality Technology 2025 Guest Engagement Study: Guest preference for direct ordering
- Deloitte, Restaurant of the Future: Branded website or app preference
Frequently asked questions
How much do third-party delivery apps charge restaurants?
In TouchBistro's national operator survey (2023), restaurants paid an average commission of 15% per online order, and nearly a quarter paid more than 20%. Actual costs depend on each restaurant's contract, service tier, marketing fees and delivery arrangement.
What percentage of restaurants offer direct online ordering?
36% of operators in TouchBistro's 2023 national survey reported direct ordering through their own website. 95% used at least one online ordering platform, averaging three solutions each.
Do customers prefer to order directly from restaurants?
In a 2025 guest engagement study, 72% of quick-service guests said they prefer ordering directly from the restaurant over a third party. A separate Deloitte survey found 40% of off-premises diners preferred a restaurant-branded website or app, versus 11% for third-party tools. Preference is not the same as behavior, but both suggest a fast direct option is worth offering.
Who owns the customer data on a third-party delivery order?
On a marketplace order, the platform controls the customer relationship and most of the data; what the restaurant can see depends on the platform's terms and integrations. A direct order lets the restaurant build its own guest list, but only if it asks for consent and has a system to store and use the data.
Should a restaurant stop using third-party delivery apps?
Not necessarily. Third-party and direct ordering are not an either/or choice. A balanced approach keeps the marketplaces that bring new guests and makes the restaurant's own channel the easy choice for repeat guests, measured by direct-order share, contribution margin by channel and repeat rate.
How to cite this report
Hennessey, B. (2026, November 19). Direct vs. Third-Party Ordering: The Margin Gap. Short Order of Success. https://shortorderofsuccess.com/research/direct-vs-third-party-ordering-margin-gap/